Defects Found After Buying a Resale Apartment in Israel: What Can You Claim from the Seller?

Defects found after buying a resale apartment in Israel: buyer remedies – Abitbol & Associés

A leak that comes back with the first winter rains, an extension built without a permit, a storage room that turns out not to belong to the apartment: some buyers discover, after receiving the keys, that the resale apartment they bought in Israel is not what they thought they were buying. Israeli law does give them remedies, but those remedies follow a precise logic that differs from the “hidden defects” warranties many foreign buyers know from home. Understanding it before signing is the best way to avoid being caught out afterwards.

I. The legal framework: “non-conformity” under the Sale Law

For a resale apartment sold by a private owner, the key statute is the Sale Law (חוק המכר, תשכ”ח-1968). It was written primarily for movable goods, but it also applies, “with the necessary modifications”, to the sale of land and rights, and only where the contract does not provide otherwise. New apartments sold by a developer are governed by a separate statute, which is not covered here.

The law does not speak of “hidden defects” but of Ee-Hatama (אי־התאמה), meaning non-conformity. The seller is in breach where, among other things, it delivers:

  • a property that differs in kind or description from the one agreed;
  • a property lacking the quality or characteristics required for its ordinary use, or for a particular purpose implied by the agreement;
  • a property that does not otherwise match what the parties agreed.

In practice, a smaller area than advertised, an illegally built room presented as part of the apartment, or defects preventing normal use of the home may all amount to non-conformity.

II. What the buyer already knew does not count

The first filter is often misunderstood: a buyer cannot rely on a non-conformity he or she knew about when the contract was made. What was seen, shown or stated in the agreement is treated as accepted.

The law also requires the buyer to inspect the property immediately after receiving it and to notify the seller of any non-conformity immediately after that inspection, or after discovering it if that comes first. Without notice, the buyer generally loses the right to rely on it. The seller, for its part, must give a buyer who asks a fair opportunity to inspect.

III. Undiscoverable and concealed defects: two decisive exceptions

The immediate-inspection rule has two exceptions, which lie at the heart of most disputes:

  • Hidden non-conformity (אי־התאמה נסתרת): if the defect could not have been found by a reasonable inspection, the buyer may rely on it despite not giving notice on delivery, provided the seller is notified as soon as it is discovered.
  • Concealed non-conformity (העלמת אי־התאמה): where the defect stems from facts the seller knew, or should have known, when the contract was made and did not disclose, the buyer may rely on it despite the inspection rules and despite any contrary clause in the contract, again provided notice is given on discovery.

General contract law points the same way. The Contracts (General Part) Law (חוק החוזים (חלק כללי), תשל”ג-1973) requires good faith in negotiations and treats as misrepresentation (הטעיה) the failure to disclose facts that the law, custom or the circumstances required to be disclosed. Misrepresentation may entitle the buyer to rescind the contract.

IV. The “AS IS” clause: limited protection for the seller

Most resale contracts include a clause in which the buyer confirms having seen the apartment and buys it “AS IS” (במצבה הנוכחי). This clause matters: it generally deprives the buyer of claims based on what a reasonable viewing would have revealed.

It does not cover everything. The law itself overrides any contrary agreement where the seller concealed a defect it knew or should have known about. How far the clause reaches for an undiscoverable defect the seller was unaware of depends on its wording and on the circumstances, and must be assessed case by case.

V. What remedies, and how fast?

Once non-conformity is established, it is a breach of contract. Depending on its seriousness and on the terms of the agreement, the buyer may seek, in particular:

  • repair of the defect or performance of what was promised;
  • damages, for example the cost of works or the loss in value of the property;
  • in the most serious cases, rescission of the contract, a heavy remedy in real estate, since the transaction has already been reported to the tax authority and often registered at the Land Registry.

As for time limits, the Sale Law sets outer deadlines for hidden non-conformity, but only for movable goods. For an apartment, what matters first is prompt notice after discovery, then the general limitation period. Delay is the most common reason claims fail.

VI. Good practice before and after signing

Before signing:

  • commission a home inspection (בדק בית) by an engineer or building expert;
  • review the building file (תיק בניין) at the municipality to compare the actual apartment with the building permit;
  • obtain a Land Registry extract (נסח טאבו) and check how the unit is described in the condominium;
  • ask the seller written questions and have the answers written into the contract, rather than relying on a general “AS IS” clause.

After receiving the keys, if a defect appears:

  • photograph and date it, and obtain an expert report;
  • send the seller a detailed written notice without delay, and allow the seller to inspect;
  • keep every exchange, and have the contract reviewed before starting major works.

Conclusion – Why work with an Israeli real estate lawyer?

Israeli law protects buyers of resale apartments, but on strict conditions: what they knew does not count, what they were slow to report may be lost, and an “AS IS” clause shifts part of the risk onto them. The outcome is often decided before signing, through the checks carried out and the drafting of the contract, and just after a defect is discovered, through the speed and form of the notice. An Israeli real estate lawyer secures both moments.

With this in mind, ABITBOL & ASSOCIES, drawing on its expertise in Israeli real estate law, supports its clients at every stage of buying a resale apartment, from due diligence and contract drafting to handling a dispute with the seller. Our lawyers make sure your interests are protected and that every step is carried out securely.

Abitbol & Associés

Abitbol & Associés

Lawyers & Notaries · Jerusalem — Paris

Jerusalem

13 Shimon Ben Shetah St., 9414713
Tel. +972 (0)2 595 63 45
Fax +972 (0)2 591 63 26

Paris

13 Avenue Hubert Germain, 75116
Tel. +33 (0)1 78 90 03 73
Fax +33 (0)1 77 74 63 99

contact@abitbol-associes.com

Abitbol Associés – Lawyers & Notaries – Paris - Jerusalem

Share this article

A question about your situation?

Our lawyers in Jerusalem and Paris review your case and get back to you promptly, in English, French or Hebrew.

Or leave us your details and we will get back to you promptly.

Your details are used only to respond to your request. Learn more: privacy policy.